Skip to main content

Week 5 Analysis: The Humanoid Robot



“Moxon’s Master” is a story written by Ambrose Bierce which tells the story of Moxon, the master, who creates a chess-playing robot. Moxon is developing a sentient conscious machine, one that can think and possesses intelligence. Although the narrator states that robots have no brains or source of thinking, he is trying to create a which he believes will be capable of thinking, acting and possessing consciousness- a robot or automaton which will be able to perform actions independent of its creator – the idea of a humanoid robot. Moxon seems to live an isolated life and the representation of the robot is what he wishes. The robot represents human cognition and social interaction, that Moxon may be experiencing. 
In the story, Moxon plays a game of chess with the robot and wins. It is apparent the robot is mad, and kills Moxon. This part of the story is very interesting because Moxon states, “definition of ‘life’ the activity of a machine is included – there is nothing in the definition that is not applicable to it. According to this sharpest of observers and deepest of thinkers, if a man during his period of activity is alive, so is a machine when in operation” (238). When the robot kills Moxon, it is portraying that the robot has the ability to feel and understand anger. It is a twist to the story because in the beginning Moxon says, “you know well enough that when I say “machine” I do not mean a man, but something that man has made and controls.” Moxon lost control of his creation. Later in the story the narrator questions what really is the truth.





Comments

  1. HI Samuel, I enjoyed reading your post I didn't read this story so I liked hearing your thoughts on it. That is interesting to think that a robot would have feelings and you wonder if it is only at certain times he has feelings and what controls that. Also to think that Moxon's creation, the robot he made ends up killing himself, these two characters have an interesting relationship as seen.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Happy Friday! I thought this an interesting story and had some intense moments. This story had my attention and wanting more. Moxon seemed to be obsessed with the idea of creating this machine, he says that it is a machine, however it had already attacked or struggle with him. The machine was stronger than Moxon and developed feelings of it’s own. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello Samuel,

    Good post! It seems that this story, Maxon’s Master, parallels Mary Shelley’s novel Frankenstein. As Dr. Frankenstein created a “monster” with sole and feelings, he underestimated the potential harm that it might wreak. It seems to me that the robot's creator, like Dr. Frankenstein, did not consider that humans are not always good moral beings and that if you infuse a creation with human feelings and emotions you have to accept the good with the bad. Maybe the chess-playing robot was more human than its creator could deal with, displaying the true range of human emotions including intelligence and aggression. I can only wonder if the moral of this tale is that humans, themselves, are really monsters and the robot was truly made in their image.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello there Samuel.
    This was a very great post to read! It was very intriguing to read, even though I haven't read this before. The creativity behind this story is personally what makes it so interesting to me, considering I am a huge fan of science fiction and non fiction science. Thank you for writing such an interesting, and in depth post, keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week 4 Analysis: The Hunt for Revenge

Samuel McDuffie Literary Analysis The Hunt for Revenge John Rollin Ridge (Yellow Bird) was born in 1827 into a distinguished Cherokee family in Georgia.  His father, John Ridge and grandfather Major Ridge were prosperous farmer and slaveholders.  Both grandfather and father were influential leaders in the dispute over how to respond to pressure from the United States to give up Cherokee Lands and move west.  He was the first Indian to publish a novel. In his work  The Life and Adventures of Joaquin Murieta, the Celebrated California Bandit  is a  contemporary account of California as it was settling. In the reading assigned, the reader is introduced to lawless men in California, known as bandits, and Joaquin Murieta. Joaquin Murieta is a Mexican-American bandit, who leaves behind a legacy of morals and bravery.  The Life and Adventures of Joaquin Murieta, tells the story of the Joaquin in the Gold-rush era, wanting to find fortune and happiness;...

Project 1

Samuel McDuffie English 205 Professor Joellen Hiltbrand March 3, 2010 Two Different Views on Love “The Luck of Roaring Camp” and Self Reliance” tell the story of different times and context. The short story of “The Luck of Roaring Camp” by Francis Bret Harte and “Self-Reliance” By James Whitfield are different themes and context but each tells a story of a certain things you need to make the most out of. Although they are two different genres and speak of two different telling’s, they both identify the meaning of love, hope and purity through harsh times.  Francis Bret Harte was an American short-story writer and poet who wrote short fiction featuring miners, gamblers and other figures during the California Gold Rush. He wrote the short story “The Luck of Roaring Camp”. The short story speaks of a woman named Cherokee Sal who is the only woman in the camp. She has gone into a difficult labor and once the child is born, Sal dies after, leaving the boy in the hands of the mi...

Analysis Week 7: A Immigrant Succeeding

Yone Noguchi was born in Nagoya, Japan. He studied Haiku and Zen Buddhism, English philosophy and poetry at a university in Tokyo. He later moved to California. He was the first literary figure in two cultures to arrive in California. The short story “Some Stories of My Western Life” is an creative nonfiction of Yone Noguchi’s life as he left his homeland to go to California.  Yone Noguchi tells the story of his journey to California. In the beginning of the story Noguchi says that his friends wished him godspeed and how he became sad his eldest brother came to say goodbye to him from Yokohama. In the story, Noguchi shares his excitement when he sees “a vastness of water”. This one particular experience, the reader finds itself returning to a younger time of Noguchi’s life. He speaks of his first fishing party on the river Kiso, many years ago and how he got sick by the motion of the water. Here is when the reader finds out of Noguchi’s dislike of the sea. This is interesting to...